Stories from the Forge
Franklin and the Turkey

Every November, someone repeats the story that Benjamin Franklin wanted the turkey to be the national bird instead of the bald eagle.
The story is half right. Franklin never proposed the turkey to Congress, and there was no vote. But he did make the argument, in writing, in a letter to his daughter. And the letter is funnier than the legend.
The Letter
On January 26, 1784, Franklin was in France, serving as the American minister. He wrote to his daughter, Sarah Bache, in Philadelphia. The full text is on Founders Online, the National Archives collection of the founders’ papers.
Most of the letter is not about birds at all. It is about the Society of the Cincinnati, a new organization of Continental Army officers. Franklin did not like the idea of a hereditary order passed from father to son, and he spent several pages saying so.
The birds come up because of the society’s badge, which featured an eagle.
The Eagle
Franklin passes along a complaint he had heard, that the eagle on the badge looked too much like a turkey. Then he gives his own opinion of the bald eagle, and it is not kind.
“I wish the bald eagle had not been chosen as the representative of our country,” he writes. He calls it “a bird of bad moral character.”
His case: the eagle is too lazy to fish for itself. It sits on a dead tree and waits for the fishing hawk to catch something, then steals the fish. Franklin adds that the eagle is also a coward: the little kingbird, no bigger than a sparrow, chases it away.
The Turkey
So Franklin says he is not entirely displeased that the badge’s bird looks like a turkey. The turkey, he writes, is “a much more respectable bird,” and a true native of America, where eagles can be found anywhere in the world.
He admits the turkey is a little vain and silly. But he calls it a bird of courage, one that would not hesitate to attack a British grenadier who invaded its farmyard.
That is the whole argument. It was a private letter to his daughter, half serious and half joke, written about a medal. The eagle had already been chosen for the Great Seal in 1782. Franklin was not campaigning to change it.
Why the Story Lasts
The legend survives because it is a little bit true and a lot of fun. Franklin really did think the turkey was the more admirable bird, and he said so in the kind of language that still sounds like him: dry, practical and a little mischievous.
It also says something about Franklin. A man who helped write the Declaration of Independence and negotiate the end of the Revolution still took the time to defend a farmyard bird to his daughter. History is full of serious people with a sense of humor.
Franklin Was Right
We liked the letter enough to make a shirt about it. The National Bird Turkey Shirt, Franklin Was Right Thanksgiving Tee takes Franklin’s side, with all due respect to the eagle. It is a good shirt for Thanksgiving dinner, especially if someone at the table is going to bring this story up anyway.
For what we actually know about the Plymouth harvest of 1621, turkey included, read What We Actually Know About 1621.
