Stories from the Forge
What We Actually Know About 1621

Most of what Americans picture about the “first Thanksgiving” comes from paintings made almost three hundred years later. The written record of what happened at Plymouth in the fall of 1621 is much smaller. It fits in a single paragraph, plus a few lines from a second source.
That is worth knowing before the turkey goes in the oven.
The Paragraph
The main account comes from Edward Winslow, one of the English colonists, in a letter he sent home in December 1621. It was printed in London the next year in a book now known as Mourt’s Relation. The Pilgrim Hall Museum keeps the full passage and the other primary source together.
Winslow writes that after “our harvest being gotten in,” the governor sent four men out hunting birds so the colony could celebrate. He says many of the Native people came, including Massasoit, the Wampanoag leader, with about ninety men. The English entertained and fed them for three days. The Wampanoag men went out, killed five deer, and gave them to the governor and other leaders.
That is nearly all of it.
The Second Source
The only other primary source is William Bradford, the colony’s governor, in his history Of Plymouth Plantation. He does not describe the gathering. He describes the season: plenty of fish and waterfowl, a good supply of venison and corn, and “great store of wild turkeys.”
So turkey was around that fall. Neither writer says it was served at the meal.
What the Record Leaves Out
A few things people assume are not in either account.
- The word “thanksgiving.” Neither Winslow nor Bradford calls the event a thanksgiving. For the English, a day of thanksgiving was a religious day set apart for prayer and worship, not a feast.
- A date. The harvest was in, which points to late September or October. No one wrote down the day.
- Women and children. Winslow mentions men. Historians at Pilgrim Hall and Wampanoag scholars both think women and children from both communities were very likely there, simply unrecorded.
- An invitation. The text does not say whether the Wampanoag were invited or arrived for another reason. Historians still disagree.
The Wampanoag Side
Both written accounts are English. The Wampanoag had lived in the area, which they called Patuxet, for thousands of years, and their perspective has mostly come down through oral history and their own historians.
What that perspective stresses is context. Between about 1616 and 1619, diseases brought by European ships killed a large share of the Native people of coastal New England. The Wampanoag were weakened and under pressure from rival nations. The English had lost nearly half their own people in their first winter. That spring, Massasoit and the colonists agreed to an alliance, each promising to help the other if attacked.
Seen that way, the gathering in the fall was diplomacy as much as dinner: two wary communities, a few months into an alliance, eating together for three days through translators. Mashpee Wampanoag and Plimoth Patuxet Museums historians quoted in a Smithsonian article on the 400th anniversary describe it in just those terms.
Keeping Fact and Story Apart
None of this has to spoil the holiday. Thanksgiving as Americans keep it took shape over centuries, and it means what families make it mean.
It is still worth telling the 1621 story straight: a harvest, a hunt, ninety guests, five deer, three days, and an alliance that was only a few months old. The real version is more interesting than the painting.
For how the holiday got its fixed date much later, see next week’s story on how Thanksgiving got its Thursday. And for another short history this month, read From Armistice Day to Veterans Day.

2 thoughts on “What We Actually Know About 1621”
Comments are closed.