American Heritage, Stories

How Thanksgiving Got Its Thursday

A feather quill in a brass inkwell, a cream letter closed with a red wax seal and a brass candlestick on an antique wooden desk by a window, beside the headline 'It took a letter.' and a Read the story button. Liberty Forge Built logo in the corner.

Thanksgiving is this Thursday, November 26. That date feels as fixed as the Fourth of July, but it is not very old. For most of American history there was no national Thanksgiving at all, and the version we have now was settled by Congress in 1941.

Getting there took a magazine editor, a president in the middle of a war, and an argument about Christmas shopping.

Before 1863

Days of thanksgiving were common in early America, but states and towns set their own. George Washington issued a national proclamation in 1789, naming Thursday, November 26 of that year as a day of thanks for the new Constitution. The National Archives has the story of that proclamation. It was a single occasion, not a yearly holiday.

For decades after that, a family in one state might give thanks in November while a family a few states over did it on a different day, or not at all.

The Editor Who Kept Asking

Sarah Josepha Hale edited the Lady’s Book, one of the most widely read magazines of her time. She also wrote “Mary Had a Little Lamb.” And she believed the country needed one shared day of thanksgiving.

On September 28, 1863, she wrote to President Lincoln. The letter is in the Abraham Lincoln Papers at the Library of Congress. “For the last fifteen years,” she told him, she had argued for the idea in her magazine. She asked for “the last Thursday in November,” which fell on the 26th that year, and suggested he name the day by presidential proclamation and urge every governor to do the same.

Lincoln’s Proclamation

Five days later, on October 3, 1863, Lincoln issued a proclamation setting apart “the last Thursday of November next” as a day of Thanksgiving and Praise. Secretary of State William Seward countersigned it.

The timing matters. The country was, in the proclamation’s words, “in the midst of a civil war of unequalled magnitude and severity.” Gettysburg had been fought that July. The proclamation asks Americans to give thanks and also to care for those who had become widows and orphans in the war.

Historians do not know how much Hale’s letter moved Lincoln, but the Library of Congress credits it with helping. Either way, presidents kept issuing a Thanksgiving proclamation every year after that, and the last Thursday of November became the custom.

The Year There Were Two Thanksgivings

The custom ran into trouble in 1939. That November had five Thursdays, so the last one fell on November 30. President Franklin Roosevelt worried that a short Christmas shopping season would hurt an economy still recovering from the Depression, and he moved Thanksgiving up a week.

Not everyone went along. According to the National Archives, 32 states followed Roosevelt’s date and 16 kept the last Thursday. For two years, part of the country ate turkey one week and the rest ate it the next.

The 1941 Law

Congress settled it. On October 6, 1941, the House passed a joint resolution making the last Thursday in November the legal Thanksgiving Day. The Senate changed it to the fourth Thursday, which works the same way in most years and avoids the problem in Novembers with five Thursdays. The House agreed, and Roosevelt signed it on December 26, 1941.

That is the rule we still follow. This year November has only four Thursdays, so the last Thursday and the fourth Thursday are the same day. Hale and Lincoln would both recognize it.

Why the Date Story Is Worth Knowing

The holiday did not arrive finished. It was asked for, argued over and written into law by people who thought a shared day of thanks was worth the trouble. That is a good thing to know while you are passing the potatoes.

For the much older story behind the holiday, read What We Actually Know About 1621. And for another holiday with a long road to its date, see From Armistice Day to Veterans Day.